Holiday Gifts Starting at $3

Click to Shop Now

Spend $40+ on Blue Buffalo, earn $10 Petco Cash!

Click to Shop Now

*Terms Apply

FREE Pet-Friendly Events

Click to Shop Now

Account
Pals Rewards

Search...

Two Easy Ways to Start Earning Rewards!
Become a member today!
Members-only pricing and offers, personalized care notifications, Vital Care points back on every purchase and more!
Already a member? Sign in
Become a credit card member today!
Earn 2X Pals Rewards points at Petco
when you use Petco Pay!
APPLY NOW
Learn More About Petco Pay Benefits

Dog Supplies/
Dog Toys

Peanut Butter Dog Toys

New Arrivals
Tough Toys
Plush Toys
Chew Toys
Interactive & Treats Dispensing Toys
Rope & Tug Toys
Fetch & Outdoor Dog Toys
Puppy Toys
Toys Storage

Sponsored

Unique design cleans down to the gumline

Greenies Original Large Natural Dog Dental Care Chews Oral Health Dog Treats
(4.6)
Starting at $9.98
Greenies Original Petite Size Flavor Adult Natural Dental Dog Treats
(4.5)
Starting at $5.78
Greenies Original Regular Size Flavor Adult Natural Dental Dog Treats
(4.6)
Starting at $5.78

Get It Today

Same Day Delivery

Pick Up In-Store

Dental Dog Toys

Fetch & Outdoor Dog Toys

Interactive & Treat Dispensing Dog Toys

Tough & Durable Dog Toys

One Time Delivery

Free Pickup Today

Same Day Delivery

Autoship

Benebone

KONG

Nylabone

Pet Qwerks

Playology

$5-$10

$10-$15

$15-$25

$25-$50

Puppy

All Breeds

Plush

Vegetable

Assorted

Less than 1 lb

1-5 lbs

5-10 lbs

10-20 lbs

2

1 - 20 of 20 results

Sort by

Relevance

Get It Today

Same Day Delivery

Pick Up In-Store

+ More Choices Available
KONG Easy Treat Peanut Butter Flavor for Dogs
(400) reviews
Same Day Eligible
+ More Choices Available
Nylabone Gourmet Style Strong Stick Peanut Butter Chew Dog Toy
(33) reviews
Same Day Eligible
Nylabone Freezer Bone Peanut Butter Chew Puppy Toy
(106) reviews
$9.99
Same Day Eligible
KONG Stuff'N Peanut Butter Dog Treats
(86) reviews
$12.49
Same Day Eligible

Earn 3X Petco cash! Exclusive gifts for Santa's favorites. Shop Holiday.

Playology Puppy Teething Bone Peanut Butter Dog Toy
(114) reviews
$19.99
Same Day Eligible
KONG Stuff 'N Real Peanut Butter
(196) reviews
$7.99
Same Day Eligible
Playology Peanut Butter Scented Crunchy Femur Bone Jumbo Dog Toy
(11) reviews
$14.99
Same Day Eligible
Nylabone Dura Power Chew Dog Toy Value Pack
(113) reviews
$9.69
Same Day Eligible

Nylabone Power Chew Dog Toy Peanut Butter X-Large/Souper - 50+ lbs.
(296) reviews
$19.49
Same Day Eligible
Nylabone Moderate Chew FlexiChew Bone Peanut Butter & Bacon Orange & Blue XX-Small/Tiny - Up to 8 lbs.
(71) reviews
$12.49
Same Day Eligible
+ More Choices Available
Playology Squeaky Chew Stick Peanut Butter Dog Toy
(339) reviews
Same Day Eligible
+ More Choices Available
Benebone Peanut Wishbone Dog Chew Toy
(163) reviews

Where the pets GO to unleash their inner superfan. Gear up with jerseys, toys, accessories & more. Shop Now.

Playology Squeaky Chew Ball Peanut Butter Dog Toy
(274) reviews
$26.99
Same Day Eligible
Playology Plush Squeaky Bone Peanut Butter Dog Toy
(191) reviews
$23.99
Same Day Eligible
+ More Choices Available
KONG Marathon Peanut Butter Chew Dog Treat
(19) reviews

+ More Choices Available
Playology Dual Layer Ring Peanut Butter Dog Toy
(225) reviews
Same Day Eligible
+ More Choices Available
Benebone Peanut Dental Dog Chew Toy
(55) reviews
Playology Peanut Butter Scented Squeaky Pinecone Jumbo Dog Toy
(9) reviews
$13.99
Same Day Eligible
Pet Qwerks Incredibubbles Peanut Butter Flavor Bubbles for Dogs
(13) reviews
$5.99
Playology Dual Layer Bone Peanut Butter Dog Toy
(422) reviews
$9.99
Same Day Eligible

Related Searches

Dog Food Plush Dog Toys Puppy Toys Dog Chew Toys Dog Treats & Chews Pet Life Dog Toys PetSafe Dog Toys KONG Dog Toys Woof Dog Toys Playology Dog Toys Best Dog Toys Best Fetch & Outdoor Dog Toys Best Dog Chew Toys Best Puppy Toys

Related Articles & Questions

Home & Habitat
Make Easy & Safe DIY Dog Toys from Common Household Items
Try reusing items around your home for these DIY dog toys.
Updated on October 23rd, 2025
Home & Habitat
Top 10 Best Holiday Dog Gifts: Treats & Toys Your Pup Will Adore!
Choosing the perfect gift for family and friends can often be a challenge. Fortunately, ‘fetching’ the perfect holiday treats and toys for your pup can be just as fun as your average game of, well...
Updated on October 23rd, 2025
Health & Wellness
Can My Dog See Colors?
Learn what colors your dog sees and make playtime more fun for both of you.
Updated on December 1st, 2025
Seasonal Topics
Best Dog Water Toys & Cooling Products to Help Your Pup Beat the Heat
Find your pup the best water toys and cooling products for their best summer yet!
Updated on June 9th, 2026
Training & Behavior
How To Choose a Dog Toy
Discover how to choose a dog toy tailored to your pet’s breed, size, and personality to keep them engaged and happy.
Updated on April 22nd, 2026
Vet Q & A
My playful dog needs toys! What are the best and safest options?
Chewing on toys is a great activity for dogs to help them burn off energy, keep them occupied, and help keep them from chewing on other things in the house that are inappropriate for them to chew on. Dogs have individual preferences for the types of toys they chew on, so it may take a bit of experimenting to find out what Abby likes. Rope toys, soft toys and rubber chew toys are all good options. There are even puzzle toys where you can hide food and that will keep your pup busy trying to get the food out. Avoid any toys that are too hard- you should be able to easily dent the surface with a fingernail, as anything harder than that could lead to fracturing of the teeth. Avoid offering bones, antler, and similar objects for this reason. Always supervise play, and if you notice your dog trying to eat any pieces of the toys, take them away, as the pieces could cause a blockage of the intestines that could lead to the need for surgery to remove it.
Updated on September 24th, 2025
Training & Behavior
My dog destroys toys. Best durable toys for boredom when I'm at work?
Have a few toys at home but only give 1-2 at a time. Change it out every day for a different set to prevent boredom. You can try kongs or the type of toys that are puzzles and release food every time they figure it out. Instead of bones, invest into water buffalo horns or elk antlers, they are much more durable
Updated on September 24th, 2025
Food & Nutrition
What toys or games stimulate an energetic dog not food-motivated?
Yes, I do! I love the Nina Ottosson puzzle toys for dogs. The dog has to solve a puzzle to get a treat, and there are varying levels of difficulty. Something like this would be great for Conan. I hope this helps.
Updated on September 24th, 2025
Training & Behavior
My dog destroys all toys. What are the best options for super chewers?
Some dogs are chewers. It is good that he does not chew inappropriately. As long as he chews just toys, you'll likely need to keep replacing them. You can try rotating toys so that Berlin does not have an opportunity to totally destroy them. As soon as you see some wear, take it away and replace it. Use caution when giving bones as they could fracture a tooth or teeth.
Updated on September 24th, 2025
Training & Behavior
My hyper dog needs constant play. What toys or chews can help?
Hi there and thank you for using Petco Pet Education Center, formerly Petcoach to address your concern. I would recommend offering more toys that keep Benny busy longer. Kong toys that you can fill with peanut butter work great and you can find the kong toys online or at your local pet store. You can also try NaturVet Quiet Moments calm chews with melatonin which can also be found online or at your local PetCo. I hope this helps! Please let me know if you have any other questions or concerns and I would be more than happy to help you further.
Updated on September 24th, 2025

Customer Care
Services
Corporate

Keep In Touch

Email Address*

By signing up, you consent to receive updates, special offers, program communications and other information via email from Petco.

*Providing your email address means you agree to Petco's Terms of Use and have read our Financial Incentive Terms and Privacy Policy

Download Our App

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Site Map
Website Accessibility Policy

©2026 Petco Animal Supplies, Inc. All rights reserved.

Petco Animal Supplies, Inc.® is not an insurer and is not engaged in the business of insurance. PetCoach, LLC is a licensed insurance producer, not an insurer, and a wholly owned subsidiary of Petco Animal Supplies, Inc. The Petco name is used for the brand name. In California, PetCoach, LLC does business as PetCoach Insurance Solutions Agency (CA License No. 0M10414).

Pet insurance plans are marketed and offered by PetCoach, LLC. Pet Insurance plans are underwritten in all states except California by National Casualty Company (NAIC #11991, Columbus, OH), and in California by Veterinary Pet Insurance Company (NAIC #42285, Columbus, OH), both insurers are subsidiaries of Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company. Prior to October 23, 2023, pet insurance policies were underwritten by United States Fire Insurance Company (NAIC #21113. Morristown, NJ).

Pre-existing conditions are not covered. Waiting periods, annual deductible, co-insurance, benefit limits and exclusions may apply. Click here for all terms and conditions. Products, schedules, discounts, and rates may vary and are subject to change. More information available at checkout. Enroll at petco.com/petco-insurance.