I don't have a dog, but I do have a horse and do some training with cookies. This little pouch is great! Instead of having a pocket of crumbs at the end of the day, I was able to keep my pockets clean and the treats easily accessible. I appreciate that it's easy to wash with dish soap so I don't have to worry about anything nasty growing in there. I like the magnetic closure as it kept the treats from falling out as I moved around, but also kept them easily accessible when I reached in. The clip stayed on my belt nicely and seemed secure as I moved around. I haven't tested it under saddle yet, but I don't think it will fall off.

Pros: nice and big with enough room for treats and a ball for fetch! Easy to clean and access while out on a walk. Cons: easy to access for me also means easy to access for dogs. More than once when I have sat down at the park, other dogs (my guy is not very treat motivated, so he doesn't care, but other dogs at the dog park know that I am the Treat Dealer) have shoved their nose in there and started eating. Also, the clip slides right out of my pocket too easily; it has been dropped more than once.

This a great treat pouch. It’s easy to clean. Clips onto my jeans easily. It’s really cute and a nice material. Made well and sturdy for long outings and holds a bunch of treats. The magnet helps keep the treats from falling out.

This treat holder is made of a silicone material that clips easily to your belt. It holds plenty of treats that I used on my walk with my dog to help him learn leash manners. The treats were handy and easy to grab to reinforce his behavior. Several times he slowed down to look back at me in anticipation of being rewarded for being a good boy. The material is easy to clean. The opening doesn't have a closure. I didn't have an issue but not sure if it would be a problem for treats to fall out if set down. It is slightly small so someone with big hands may have trouble getting their hands in for the treats on the bottom.

Perfect treat holder for training! Clasp is magnetic and secure, but very easy to quickly open, grab a treat hands free, and then it closes automatically. Secure clip on the back and the silicone makes it really easy to keep clean.

Overall a decent and functional treat pouch. It closes back up well to prevent accidentally spilling treats out. The material does make it so that treat crumbs stick to it a lot, but it's also able to be rinsed off which balances some of that out.

This is a great container for training treats. It clips onto my belt snug. The magnet closure is secure yet easy to open. Works really well and I love the color! I’ve been using it when training my Rottweiler and it keeps the treats handy and easy to access. Would definitely recommend

This is the perfect pouch for training with my eclectic parrot! Unlike with my dogs, I don’t use dry treats, but small pieces of vegetables as a reward, so I can’t put that in a traditional fabric treat pouch because it would get all wet and dirty on the inside. This silicone pouch on the other hand is great because it’s waterproof, does not leak, and can be easily rinsed and/or washed. It is nice that the pouch closes with magnets, but that’s also the only thing that sometimes makes it hard to quickly grab a treat out of it because the magnets are pretty strong. But that does prevent it from opening if you drop it.