I'm not typically one to write a review, but these were a game changer for me and my newly adopted pittie. I tried a few different brands and flavors, but she didn't seem to care about them after the first couple. I recently switched her over to a salmon and sweet potato food, and she loved it, so I figured I'd try a fish based treat. She loves them. We had been trying to learn "sit" and "come" for a week, but she didn't have motivation, within 2 days, she now knows both and has much better leash manners because she knows where I keep the good stuff. The downside: the bag isn't the biggest, but at the price point, I'd say it's fair. They smell like fish food.... But they come in a resealable bag, so take what you need and seal the stink away.

hope the bites are smaller so it could last longer. Since each bite is hard, I cannot break it smaller. Smells good but my puppy doesn't seems to be as attracted to it as the purebites salmon. Also, if the bag could be designed to stand on its own, it would be nice.