The pup loves them. I stick one in his kong and it keeps him occupied awhile. These smell so good i wish i could eat them too.

These treats smell delicious. My two dogs go crazy for them. My only problem is that there was maybe three clusters in the bag and the rest was just crumbles. It just looked like oats in the bag. I was able to use them with my dogs food, but it was a real disappointment.

My two really liked these and to get both of them to agree on something is rare. my only issue is they really fall apart, leaving a ton of crumbles on the bottom of the bag. So, instead of having actual treats for them, I just sprinkled the left overs on their food. They enjoyed that just as much.

These treats smell delicious; was tempted to try them to see what they tasted like but refrained. My only knock is much of it was very broken, basically crumbs. Makes me wonder if I just got bad luck, or if this is a consistent problem?…Otherwise, would recommend. My dog loved them!

My dogs love these treats. They seem healthier than a lot of popular treats with no artificial colors (which I've never understood why dog food and treats have coloring - the dogs can't see it and could care less). They advertise that they are well sized for training treats, and I'll verify that. I got my first couple of bags specifically to put in a challenge toy where I needed something big enough it wouldn't just fall out like a typical round training treat, but not so large they couldn't get it out at all, and it worked perfectly. I actually met some of the company owners at a Pet Expo and they seem genuinely committed to providing good quality treats for our fur babies, so I like supporting that. I'll be keeping these on hand for my gang.

My dog is obsessed with these! Very much so as they smell like a bakery and they could definitely pass as human treats but I don't suggest trying. We sprinkled them onto other chews for him and he LOVED them.

My 7 month old puppy has tried to like these treats. I have given them to him three times. He chews, spits it out, licks it, picks it back up and tries chewing again, shakes his head, spits it back out. For some reason he just doesn’t like them. He has not seemed to be a picky eater as he has always eaten everything else without issue.

My dog was not a fan of these treats at first. He spit them out the first few times I offered them to him, but after awhile he started to eat them. They are really crunchy, so that may be why he was hesitant at first. They smell really good too!