Petco Text Logo
Petco Pet Logo
  • Two Easy Ways to Start Earning Rewards!

    rewards header
    Become a member today!
    Members-only pricing and offers, personalized care notifications, Vital Care points back on every purchase and more!
    Petco Pay LogoBecome a credit card member today!

    Earn 2X Pals Rewards points at Petco
    when you use Petco Pay!

    APPLY NOW
    Learn More About Petco Pay Benefits

How will rehoming my timid cat affect my outgoing cat's personality?

Updated on September 23, 2025

Pet's info: Cat | Maine Coon | Female | spayed | 1 year and 9 months old | 10 lbs

I have two kittens that I adopted about 7 months ago when they were eight weeks old. One was clearly very timid and the other was outgoing. I am extremely happy with my outgoing cat she is exactly what I want in a pet. The other one is very timid and not what I want in a cat. I raised them according to being as outgoing as possible in Social. My question is... will the personality of my good cat change if I give her sister away and replace her with an outgoing kitten?

1 Answer

Most Helpful Answer

Dr. Melanie, BVSc MS

Answered By Dr. Melanie, BVSc MS

Veterinarian

Published on January 24, 2017

All cats have different personalities, and I would worry about what would happen to your existing cat if you give her sister away. They are likely very bonded to each other, and losing her might have an adverse effect on the outgoing cat's personality. Instead of giving the sister away, I recommend focusing a lot of attention on the timid cat. I apologize if I suggest something you've tried before, but I would give her lots of love and attention when she approaches you. Give her treats and praise her when she shows outgoing behaviors. By reinforcing the behaviors you want to see from her with praise and treats, that will encourage her be more social, thus transforming her into the type of cat you'd like.
Vote Icon1Pet Parents found this answer helpful

Smart Picks for Smart Questions

Have A Vet Question?

Book an appointment with the pros – our expert vets are here to help.

Share

Styled arrow button